Mystery Beast – Danum Valley, Borneo

These two camera trap pictures from Borneo’s Danum Valley have created quite some discussion among experts and – so far as I know – the jury is still out on what they are.

What do people think?

HearnPeculiarDanum-D0201578

HearnPeculiarDanum-D0201583

Jon

14 Comments
  1. Vladimir Dinets 8 years ago

    Any reason it can’t be a hairy-nosed otter? I can’t think of any off the top of my head.

  2. Anonymous 8 years ago

    Could it be an Otter Civet? I’m not an expert on this though so I am probably wrong.

  3. tai haku 8 years ago

    Hose’s civet maybe?

  4. Anonymous 8 years ago

    It does look like Hose’s Civet. The Arkive picture looks pretty similar to this one – and the hose’s civet has got a long tail.

  5. Profile photo of John Fox
    John Fox 8 years ago

    Is the front paw in the first photo of any diagnostic use? Mustelid was as far as I got.

  6. nicolas gaidet 8 years ago

    the long tail, white belly and large snout make it looks like a Hose’s Civet. The rather short legs, short ears, and the U-shaped back (second picture) are more otter-like…

  7. Matthew + Maureen 8 years ago

    It’s definitely an otter, the hunched shape of the spine in photo 2, the stiff down-pointing vibrissae and the taper of the tail are diagnostic for me. Hose’s Civet has much bigger ears and longer legs, by the look of its photo.

    Is it a hairy-nosed otter? The length of the head makes that more likely than smooth-coated for me, so barring an undiscovered species of otter (!) I would say hairy-nosed. These photos aren’t good enough to ignore the possibility of strange shadow/exposure effects making some features look a little odd.

  8. Stefanie 8 years ago

    It looks like an otter to me too. The tail is broad at the base and then gets more narrow, while the long tail of the Hose’s civet has more the same diameter from base to tip.

  9. Reza Lubis 8 years ago

    its definitely an Otter. Having seen several hairy nosed otters in both sumatra and kalimantan, the above picture have some indication of Hairy Nose! but the lack of possibilty to see the rhinarium part and how natural the color of the fur is (HNO that i observe has a very dark brown color compare to 3 other asian otter species),. There is also possibilty that this is the asian version of Lutra lutra which is at the moment in Sumatra/Borneo is more unknown than hairy nose. I suggest to put more camera in the area, then we will have more picture to study, Better resolution photo (if available) also will be very helpful.

    • Profile photo of Jon Hall
      Jon Hall 8 years ago

      HI Reza, thanks. I will send you the pictures by email

      cheers

      jon

  10. Profile photo of Jon Hall
    Jon Hall 8 years ago

    Thanks to everyone for all these comments which I am sure will give added food for thought to those trying to identify the species. My feeling when I first saw them was Hairy Nosed Otter but the scientists in the Danum had a lot of reasons why that was not the species in the photo. Those same scientists have changed their minds a little as the pictures are not great quality and some of the reasons why its not a Lutra sumatrana might just be tricks of the light etc. Hose’s Civet seems unlikely according to those very familiar with that species. Otter Civet even less likely.

    So I think Reza’s reply above – that it could be either L. lutra or L.sumatrana is about as good as anyone can say at the moment. If anyone catches the beast or gets better shots hopefully we will hear.
    Jon

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


*

©2020 Jon Hall. www.mammalwatching.com | jon@mammalwatching.com | | Privacy Policy

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

Create Account