Common dolphins reshuffled

A new paper analyzed the systematics of Delphinus and found that D. capensis is not a valid species. Apparently, there are still two species: the long-billed D. bairdii, pretty much endemic to California, and the very widespread and variable D. delphis, with at least three subspecies (including dwarf D. d. ponticus in the Black Sea and very long-beaked D. d. tropicalis in the Indian Ocean).

  1. mikehoit 7 years ago

    To clarify – is the D. tropicalis of this study the same form as that named D. capensis in (e.g.) Shirihai et al?

    • Author
      vdinets 7 years ago

      I meant capensis – sorry for the typo.

      • mikehoit 7 years ago

        Ah, thanks – I had wondered if maybe there had been a nomenclatural change. Really interesting conclusions in that paper, thanks for posting it.

  2. morganchurchill 7 years ago

    Not terribly surprising, but part of me is disappointed that there was no nuclear data included, some of which was previously sampled. Phylogenies based on a single gene can be inaccurate, as acknowledged by the authors themselves, and Amaral DID sample some nuclear DNA in her study, so at least some sequences were available.

    The morphology was almost an afterthought of this study. They could have at least done some basic statistics on the data, which would have probably supported their conclusions. As someone who is into cranial morphometrics, its a bit disappointing to see it’s application completely ignored.

    • Author
      vdinets 7 years ago

      I agree, with nuclear data these conclusions might still be overtuned. I find it a bit suspicious that in some places two morphotypes occur together.

      • morganchurchill 7 years ago

        that is my concern as well. Rigorous morphometric analysis would be key here. After all it’s possible that the two “morphs” actually show greater variation, and the very little morphologic data they showed in the paper may suggest intermediate forms, which basically just means that the morphs are extreme endpoints in variation and not significantly different.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



©2022 Jon Hall. | | | | Privacy Policy

Log in with your credentials


Forgot your details?

Create Account