https://www.yahoo.com/news/tall-tale-study-reveals-giraffes-four-species-not-194024390.html
Interesting article on the split of the Giraffe. Nice to add new species without going anywhere:-)
Andrew
Related Articles
-
Mammals in the news
Jon Hall, , Africa, Oriental, 0
Here’s a few recent articles that caught my eye. Golden Cats have had a good deal of publicity the...
-
New Trip Report: Malawi
Jon Hall, , Africa, 0
A report by Dominic Couzens from a country not frequently mammal-watched in! Malawi, 2015: Dominic Couzens, 5 days & 26 species including Marsh Mongoose, Harrison’s...
-
New Trip Report – Kenya
Jon Hall, , Africa, 0
Kenya, 2013: Indri Tours, 12 days & 35 species including Yellow spotted Hyrax, Serval and Caracal. Jon
-
New (old) Trip Report – Southern Africa
Jon Hall, , Africa, 0
Vladimir Dinets took a six month trip through Southern Africa back in 2008, visiting South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Zambia, Malawi, Mozambique,...
-
Ethiopian mammal
matthhias, , Africa, 0
Dear All, We are working on a small camera trap project to see what is left of wildlife in...
-
New Trip Report – South Africa
Jon Hall, , Africa, 0
A first trip report for mammalwatching.com from Jordi Palau South Africa, 2012: 2.5 weeks & 59 species including Aardvark,...
-
Info needed- Slender Mongoose and Littledale’s Whistling Rat
Jon Hall, , Africa, 6
Hi everyone! We’re visiting Kgalagadi and Namibia’s coast December and I have a few questions. I hope someone can...
-
Drills in Cameroon and beyond?
Jon Hall, , Africa, Cameroon, 6
Does anyone know whether there are reliable spots in Cameron for Drills? Or elsewhere (other than Bioko Island)? thanks...
Subscribe to mammalwatching.com
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- Jon Hall on Cottontop and White-handed Tamarins in Cartagena, Colombia
- paul carter on Gear Review: Pulsar XQ50 Thermal Imaging Scope
- Vladimir Dinets on Gear Review: Pulsar XQ50 Thermal Imaging Scope
- Vladimir Dinets on Cottontop and White-handed Tamarins in Cartagena, Colombia
- iyufera1 on Panama … November
This is not the first such paper, and it has the same problem as all previous ones: not all subspecies have been sampled. I don’t know why they didn’t sample them all; the missing subspecies are available in captivity. It’s been clear for decades that the 3 subspecies present in Kenya behave like full species; I also suspect that the extreme difference between Maasai and reticulated giraffes is due to character displacement. So it is still unclear how many species are there, and how many subspecies. I think it’s pretty safe to split giraffes into four species at this point, but it remains to be seen if there’s more.
for others, the paper is here: http://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(16)30787-4
It clearly says “Our nuclear dataset includes all currently recognized giraffe subspecies… and, importantly, the elusive Nubian giraffe (Giraffa c. camelopardalis).”
Since my previous comments have disappeared, here’s a summary.
1. Sorry, I first looked at a wrong paper. The new one provides sufficient evidence for a 4-way split. I already updated my checklist 🙂
2. But I don’t think they provide sufficient evidence for lumping of some subspecies, and I find the idea of “killing” subspecies that are clearly separate morphologically based on genetic data to be fundamentally flawed and dangerous.